Files
netbird/docs/agent-networks/modules/33-proxy-runtime.md
Maycon Santos 92a66cdd20 [management,proxy,client] 0.74.0 version (#6563)
* [management,proxy] Agent network: per-account LLM gateway (policy, metering, multi-provider) (#6555)

* [agent-network] Shared proto, OpenAPI schema, and generated types

* [agent-network] Management: store, manager, synthesizer, policy engine, provider catalog, HTTP/gRPC API

Adds the account-scoped agent-network module: provider/policy/budget CRUD and
store, the reverse-proxy service synthesizer, policy selection + limit
enforcement, the provider catalog (incl. Vertex AI and AWS Bedrock entries),
and the management HTTP + proxy gRPC surfaces.

* [management] Fix agent-network proxy-peer fan-out on affected-peer recompute

The affected-peers resolver loaded only persisted reverse-proxy services, but
agent-network services are synthesized on demand and never persisted. As a
result the embedded proxy peer was never folded into the affected set when a
client's group changed, so the proxy received no network-map update for a newly
authorised client and rejected its handshake until a full resync (restart).

loadProxyServices now merges the synthesized agent-network services (injected
via a registration hook to avoid an import cycle), so proxy peers learn newly
authorised clients immediately.

* [proxy] Reverse-proxy middleware framework, chain, and request plumbing

The per-target middleware chain (slots, dispatcher, mutation gate, metadata
merger), body capture, access-log terminal sink, and the proxy wiring that
builds + runs chains for synthesized agent-network services.

* [proxy] LLM parsers, pricing, and builtin middlewares (OpenAI, Anthropic, Vertex AI, AWS Bedrock)

Request/response parsers and SSE/event-stream metering, the embedded pricing
table, and the builtin middleware set: request parser, router, policy
limit-check/record, cost meter, guardrail, identity inject, response parser.
Includes the path-routed providers — Google Vertex AI (keyfile:: service-account
OAuth minting) and AWS Bedrock (bearer auth, invoke/converse/streaming, optional
/bedrock prefix) — plus the Models allowlist and unmeterable-publisher deny.

* [proxy] IPv6 in-place apply and TCP accept-loop hardening on netstack listeners

* [agent-network] End-to-end test suite, module docs, and deployment preset

* [agent-network] Fix codespell typos and exclude false positives

- labelgen word pool: vermillion -> vermilion, racoon -> raccoon.
- codespell ignore list: add flate (Go compress/flate package), recordin
  (a test-local identifier), and unparseable (a valid alternative spelling used
  consistently across identifiers + a metadata-value constant).

* [management] Set LastSeen on injected proxy peer in realstack test (MySQL strict-mode)

The injected embedded proxy peer had a PeerStatus with a zero LastSeen, which
serializes to '0000-00-00' and is rejected by MySQL in strict mode (SQLite
tolerates it). Set LastSeen to a valid time so SaveAccount succeeds on both
engines.

* [agent-network] Remove e2e shell-script suite from this branch

The end-to-end shell scripts under scripts/e2e/ are maintained in a separate
testing suite and are not part of this change set.

* [agent-network] Polish module docs: remove internal review scaffolding, fix links, verify diagrams

Strip PR-review framing, commit references, absolute paths, and stale internal
references from the agent-network module docs; fix broken relative links; verify
all diagrams against the current architecture. Remove the internal AI-reviewer
prompt file.

* [management] Refine session expiration handling to support 3-state encoding for SSO deadlines

* [agent-network] Relocate agentnetwork package to internals/modules

Move management/server/agentnetwork (and its catalog/, labelgen/, types/
subpackages) to management/internals/modules/agentnetwork, alongside the
reverse-proxy module, and rewrite all importers. Pure relocation: package names,
the synthesizer + affectedpeers registration hook, and store access (shared
store.Store) are unchanged, so no import cycle is introduced (affectedpeers
still depends only on the agentnetwork/types leaf).

* [agent-network] Co-locate HTTP handlers in the module (RegisterEndpoints)

Move the agent-network HTTP handlers from server/http/handlers/agentnetwork into
the module at internals/modules/agentnetwork/handlers (package handlers) and
rename the entrypoint AddEndpoints -> RegisterEndpoints, matching the
reverse-proxy module convention. Wiring in http/handler.go updated accordingly.

* Update getting started to point to rc when agent network enabled

* Add a reference to a commercial license

* Fix docs localhost link

* Fix docs localhost link

* Add private services domain note

* [management] Add agent-network telemetry metrics (#6561)

Surface agent-network adoption and usage in the self-hosted metrics
worker: distinct accounts, providers, policies, budget rules, accounts
with log collection enabled, and aggregated input/output tokens plus
cost.

Tokens and cost are summed from agent_network_request_usage (the
always-written per-request ledger) so the figures are accurate
regardless of the log-collection toggle and carry no double-counting.
All values come from a handful of indexed aggregate queries run only on
the worker's periodic tick.

Adds store.AgentNetworkMetrics with GetAgentNetworkMetrics on the Store
interface, the SqlStore implementation, and a zero-valued FileStore stub.

* Update NetBird server and proxy image versions to 0.74.0-rc.2

* [management,proxy] Reduce agent-network cognitive complexity (#6566)

Address the SonarCloud quality-gate findings in new agent-network code
by extracting focused helpers. No behavior change.

- synthesizer.go: split buildIdentityInjectConfigJSON into per-shape
  rule builders; extract mergeGuardrail from mergeGuardrails to cut
  nesting depth.
- llm_identity_inject: extract injectionEmitsAnything validation
  predicate from New.
- llm_response_parser/streaming.go: extract applyOpenAIStreamUsage and
  applyAnthropicStreamUsage (via a named anthropicStreamUsage type) and
  simplify the OpenAI scanner loop.
- reverseproxy.go: decompose ServeHTTP into serveRouteError,
  buildTargetContext, serveDirect, serveWithChain, captureRequestForChain,
  serveDeny, newResponseWriter, observeResponse, and forwardUpstream,
  preserving the defer ordering so response observation still reads the
  captured writer before it is released.

* [management] Move agent-network access-log ingest into the agentnetwork module (#6568)

The agent-network access-log ingest path (metaKey wire contract, flatten,
usage derivation, and the dual-write of the usage ledger + settings-gated
full row) lived in the reverseproxy accesslogs manager, even though the
agentnetwork module already owns the rest of that domain — types, read
(ListAccessLogs / GetUsageOverview), the budget-counter writes, and
retention cleanup.

Move it next to the rest: a stateless agentnetwork.IngestAccessLog(ctx,
store, entry) that the reverseproxy SaveAccessLog delegates to when the
entry is agent-network. Removes the agentNetworkTypes import from the
reverseproxy manager. No behavior change; the write/read table separation
is unchanged.

Adds real-store coverage for the disable->enable log-collection toggle
(usage ledger always written, full row gated) plus the metadata parse and
group-dedup helpers, which previously had no dedicated tests.

* Add session view support in the access log

* [management,proxy] Container-based agent-network e2e harness (#6577)

* [e2e] Add container-based agent-network e2e harness (Pillar 1)

Introduce a self-contained, OIDC-free e2e harness that stands up NetBird
in containers, so suites no longer depend on the hand-maintained Tilt
stack or a real IdP.

- harness brings up the combined server (management + signal + relay +
  STUN + embedded IdP) in a single container built from
  combined/Dockerfile.multistage, and mints an admin PAT through the
  unauthenticated /api/setup bootstrap (NB_SETUP_PAT_ENABLED). API access
  goes through the existing shared/management/client/rest typed client.
- the image is built via the docker CLI (BuildKit) so the Dockerfile's
  cache mounts are honored; testcontainers then runs the tagged image.
- everything is behind the `e2e` build tag so normal builds and unit
  tests never pull in testcontainers.

Adds BuildKit cache mounts to combined/Dockerfile.multistage so source
changes recompile incrementally rather than from scratch.

Pillar 1 proven by TestCombinedBootstrap: server builds, boots, mints a
PAT, and the PAT authenticates a real management API call.

* [e2e] Add management-side agent-network scenarios (Pillar 2)

Port the API-driven agent-network scenarios from the bash suites to Go,
sharing one combined server per package run (TestMain) with each test
owning its resource cleanup. Drives the /api/agent-network/* endpoints
through the shared REST client's NewRequest primitive with the generated
api types.

Scenarios:
- provider lifecycle (create/get/list/delete + 404 after delete)
- provider validation (missing api_key, unknown catalog id → 4xx)
- settings collection-toggle round-trip with cluster/subdomain immutability
- policy window floor (reject <60s enabled limit, accept at 60s)
- consumption read endpoint returns an array

All deterministic and dependency-free (dummy provider keys; no upstream
calls), so they run headless in CI.

* [e2e] Add live chat-through-proxy scenario (Pillar 3)

Stand up the full agent-network data path in containers and drive a real
chat-completion through the gateway:

- harness: a shared docker network (combined server reachable by alias),
  a proxy container built from the published reverse-proxy image
  (NB_PROXY_PRIVATE, NB_PROXY_ALLOW_INSECURE, NB_RELAY_TRANSPORT=ws to match
  the combined server's WS-multiplexed relay) with a generated self-signed
  wildcard cert, and a netbird client container that joins via a setup key.
- the combined image, proxy image, and client image default to the
  published rc.2 releases (overridable via NB_E2E_*_IMAGE; a bare local tag
  is built from source instead). Geolocation download is disabled so the
  server starts without external fetches.
- one shared domain is used for the management exposed address, the proxy
  domain, and the agent-network cluster; the proxy token is minted via the
  server CLI (global) to match the manual install.

TestChatCompletionThroughProxy provisions provider+policy+group+setup key,
runs proxy+client, drives an OpenAI chat-completion through the tunnel, and
asserts a 200 plus the ingested access-log row. Requires OPENAI_TOKEN
(skips otherwise). The provider must be created with enabled=true explicitly
— the create default is false despite the API doc.

* [e2e] Run the live chat scenario across a provider matrix

Replace the single-provider chat test with a data-driven matrix that runs
the same scenario through every provider whose credentials are present in
the environment (keys/URLs sourced from ~/.llm-keys locally, Actions
secrets in CI):

- OpenAI (chat), Anthropic (messages), Vercel, OpenRouter, Cloudflare
  (OpenAI-compatible gateways), and Bedrock (path-routed, bearer, via the
  messages shape) — covering both wire shapes and the gateway routing.
- all providers are created enabled with a unique model string so the
  proxy's connect-time snapshot carries them all and model->provider
  routing is unambiguous (provider toggles after connect don't reconcile
  to a connected proxy).
- the client supports both wire shapes (/v1/chat/completions and
  /v1/messages); Cloudflare gets the openai provider segment appended to
  its gateway URL.

Each provider must return 200 through the tunnel and produce an ingested
access-log row. Vertex is intentionally excluded from the uniform matrix:
it needs a bespoke rawPredict request shape rather than the shared
chat/messages path, so it warrants a dedicated scenario.

* [ci] Add manual workflow for the agent-network e2e suite

The e2e suite (build tag `e2e`) stands up the combined server + proxy +
client in Docker and drives live chat-completions, so it is slow and needs
provider credentials. Gate it out of normal CI (it already is, via the
build tag) and run it on demand via workflow_dispatch. Provider scenarios
skip when their secret is unset, so it degrades gracefully.

* [e2e] Add Vertex to the provider matrix; run e2e on ubuntu-latest

Vertex (Anthropic-on-Vertex) doesn't share the chat/messages wire shapes:
the model travels in a rawPredict path and the proxy mints the service
account's OAuth token. Add a Vertex client method that posts
/v1/projects/<project>/locations/<region>/publishers/anthropic/models/<model>:rawPredict
with the Vertex anthropic_version body, and wire it into the matrix as a
path-routed provider (created without a models array). It is keyed off
GOOGLE_VERTEX_SA_BASE64 + GOOGLE_VERTEX_PROJECT (region defaults to
"global", model to a pinned claude snapshot, both overridable).

Also bump the e2e workflow runner to ubuntu-latest and add the Vertex
secrets.

* Add docker/docker and docker/go-connections as direct dependencies in go.mod

* [ci] Trigger agent-network e2e workflow on push to main and pull requests

* [e2e] Fix proxy cert permission denied on Linux CI runners

The proxy bind-mounts a temp dir of self-signed certs. MkdirTemp creates
it 0700 and the key was 0600, which Docker Desktop on macOS ignores but a
non-root proxy container on Linux runners cannot traverse/read, so the
cert watcher failed with "open /certs/tls.crt: permission denied" and the
container exited. Widen the cert dir to 0755 and write the throwaway key
0644 so the proxy uid can read the bind-mounted material.

* [e2e] Build images from source by default instead of pulling rc.2

The agent-network code under test lives in this branch, so the e2e should
exercise it rather than a frozen published release. Flip the harness
default: combined/proxy/client are now built from their in-repo
Dockerfiles (combined/Dockerfile.multistage, proxy/Dockerfile.multistage,
e2e/harness/Dockerfile.client) under local tags. Pulling a published image
stays available by setting NB_E2E_*_IMAGE to a registry reference.

Builds now go through buildx --load so the Dockerfile cache mounts are
honored and the result is loaded for testcontainers. The CI workflow adds
a container-driver builder and a local layer cache (NB_E2E_BUILDX_CACHE)
persisted via actions/cache, which caches the base/apt/dep-download layers
across runs. The Go compile still re-runs each time, as BuildKit mount
caches cannot be exported to the GitHub cache.

* [e2e] Cover real providers in lifecycle + assert real consumption metering

- TestProviderLifecycle now runs per available real provider (create → get →
  list → delete → 404) instead of a single dummy provider, exercising each
  catalog's create and field round-trip. Create is offline, so it stays fast
  and burns no provider quota; falls back to a synthetic OpenAI provider when
  no keys are set.
- TestProvidersMatrix attaches a token limit (high caps, 60s window) to its
  policy, which switches on usage metering, and asserts consumption rows are
  recorded with positive token counts after the live traffic. Consumption is
  account-scoped (keyed by source group / user and window, not per provider),
  so the assertion is aggregate.
- TestProviderValidation gains invalid-upstream and blank-name cases. Create
  validation is uniform across catalogs (no per-provider required-field rules),
  so per-provider rejection cases would be redundant.

* [e2e] Assert session id propagates per provider

Each matrix request now sends a unique session id as the universal
x-session-id header and asserts it round-trips into that provider's
access-log row. This guards the session-grouping contract end to end for
every provider (header extraction runs in llm_request_parser ahead of the
parser-specific body extraction, so it is provider-agnostic).

* [e2e] Drop accidentally committed sync-phases dashboard

netbird-sync-phases.json was swept into the Pillar 1 commit by a broad
git add; it belongs to the unrelated sync-phases metrics work, not this
e2e harness. Remove it from the branch so the PR diff is scoped to the
e2e changes.

* [e2e] Revert accidentally committed sync-phase ingest spec

The netbird_sync_phase measurement spec in metrics ingest was swept into
the Pillar 1 commit; it belongs to the unrelated sync-phases metrics work,
not this e2e harness. Its emission side never landed here, so the spec was
orphaned anyway. Restore ingest/main.go to its origin/main state.

* Fix golint issues

* Fix sonar

* Add access log session test

* Fix access log tests

---------

Co-authored-by: braginini <bangvalo@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Zoltan Papp <zoltan.pmail@gmail.com>
2026-07-01 12:45:14 +02:00

19 KiB

proxy/runtime — translate + serve + log

Risk level: High — every config push from management is translated here, and the chain runs on every HTTP request to a synth target. Backward-compat impact: Additive at the wire (PathTargetOptions.middlewares, agent_network, disable_access_log, capture caps) and on the proxy Server struct (MiddlewareDataDir, MiddlewareCaptureBudgetBytes). Non-agent-network targets stay on the no-middleware fast path.

Module boundary

Turns the synth-service wire format from ProxyService.SyncMappings/GetMappingUpdate into in-process middleware chains and runs them on top of the existing httputil.ReverseProxy. Four concerns: (a) translateproto.MiddlewareConfig → validated middleware.Spec (proxy/middleware_translate.go) + self-register the eight built-ins (proxy/middleware_register.go); (b) boot + rebuild — construct the middleware.Manager, share the OTel meter, install the live-service check, rebuild per-path chains on every addMapping/modifyMapping (proxy/server.go); (c) serve — resolve chain at request time, capture bodies under a global budget, invoke RunRequest/RunResponse/RunTerminal, render deny responses, apply UpstreamRewrite (proxy/internal/proxy/reverseproxy.go); (d) log + tag — emit access-log entries with the new agent_network flag, gate emission on EnableLogCollection via DisableAccessLog (proxy/internal/accesslog).

Inert for non-agent-network targets: nil or empty chain → existing fast path (reverseproxy.go:127-139); SuppressAccessLog defaults false so the access-log middleware emits unchanged.

Files

Path Role
proxy/middleware_translate.go proto→Spec translation; slot/failmode/timeout mapping; caps
proxy/middleware_translate_test.go translator unit tests
proxy/middleware_register.go blank-imports the eight builtins for init() registration
proxy/server.go initMiddlewareManager, rebuildMiddlewareChains, isLiveService, buildMiddlewareBindings, new Server fields, protoToMapping stamps AgentNetwork/DisableAccessLog/CaptureConfig/Middlewares
proxy/internal/proxy/reverseproxy.go WithMiddlewareManager, chain dispatch, body capture, applyUpstreamRewrite/Headers, buildRequestInput, response-leg respInput identity fields
proxy/internal/proxy/reverseproxy_test.go TestBuildRequestInput_PropagatesIdentityAndGroups
proxy/internal/proxy/context.go agentNetwork, suppressAccessLog, userGroupNames on CapturedData
proxy/internal/proxy/servicemapping.go new PathTarget fields
proxy/internal/proxy/agent_network_chain_realstack_test.go end-to-end self-contained chain test
proxy/internal/accesslog/logger.go logEntry.AgentNetworkproto.AccessLog
proxy/internal/accesslog/middleware.go reads GetAgentNetwork(); gates l.log on !GetSuppressAccessLog()
proxy/internal/accesslog/middleware_test.go suppress/default/preserves-usage assertions
proxy/internal/auth/middleware_test.go tunnel-peer group propagation contract
proxy/internal/metrics/metrics.go Meter() getter for the middleware manager

Architecture & flow

Synth-service ingestion → translate → register → serve

flowchart TD
    A[Management SyncMappings/GetMappingUpdate] --> B["processMappings\nserver.go:1492"]
    B --> C{Mapping type}
    C -->|CREATED| D["addMapping → setupHTTPMapping → updateMapping"]
    C -->|MODIFIED| E["modifyMapping → cleanupMappingRoutes → setupHTTPMapping → updateMapping"]
    C -->|REMOVED| F["removeMapping → cleanupMappingRoutes → invalidateMiddlewareChains"]
    D --> G["protoToMapping\nserver.go:2181"]
    E --> G
    G --> H["translateMiddlewareConfigs\nmiddleware_translate.go:55"]
    G --> I["translateMiddlewareCaptureConfig\nmiddleware_translate.go:18"]
    H --> J["[]middleware.Spec on PathTarget"]
    I --> K["*bodytap.Config on PathTarget"]
    J --> L["proxy.AddMapping\nservicemapping.go:118"]
    K --> L
    L --> M["rebuildMiddlewareChains\nserver.go:2017 → Manager.Rebuild"]
    F --> N["Manager.Invalidate(serviceID)"]

Per-request lifecycle through the chain + accesslog

sequenceDiagram
    autonumber
    participant C as Client
    participant M as accesslog.Middleware
    participant A as auth.Middleware (Protect)
    participant RP as ReverseProxy.ServeHTTP
    participant CH as middleware.Chain
    participant U as Upstream
    C->>M: HTTP request
    M->>M: NewCapturedData(requestID), WithCapturedData(ctx)
    M->>A: next.ServeHTTP
    A->>A: Private → ValidateTunnelPeer → stamp UserID/Email/Groups/GroupNames/AuthMethod
    A->>RP: next.ServeHTTP
    RP->>RP: findTargetForRequest → targetResult
    RP->>RP: stamp ServiceID/AccountID/AgentNetwork/SuppressAccessLog on CapturedData
    RP->>RP: resolveChain via Manager.ChainFor
    alt chain == nil or Empty
        RP->>U: httputil.ReverseProxy.ServeHTTP (fast path)
    else chain non-empty
        RP->>RP: bodytap.CaptureRequest (global budget)
        RP->>CH: RunRequest
        CH-->>RP: denyOutput? requestMeta + upstreamRewrite
        alt deny
            RP->>C: RenderDenyResponse
        else allow
            RP->>RP: capturingWriter + applyUpstreamRewrite/Headers
            RP->>U: httputil.ReverseProxy.ServeHTTP(respWriter)
            U-->>RP: response
            RP->>CH: RunResponse (respInput carries UserGroups)
            RP->>CH: RunTerminal (merged request+response metadata)
        end
    end
    RP-->>M: handler returns
    M->>M: build logEntry incl. AgentNetwork
    alt SuppressAccessLog == true
        M->>M: skip l.log; still trackUsage
    else default
        M->>M: l.log → goroutine SendAccessLog
    end

EnableLogCollection suppression path

flowchart LR
    S["agentnetwork.Settings.EnableLogCollection"] --> B["synthesizer: target.DisableAccessLog = !EnableLogCollection"]
    B --> P["proto PathTargetOptions.disable_access_log (field 13)"]
    P --> T["protoToMapping reads GetDisableAccessLog()\nserver.go:2211"]
    T --> M["PathTarget.DisableAccessLog\nservicemapping.go:47"]
    M --> R["ServeHTTP: cd.SetSuppressAccessLog\nreverseproxy.go:106"]
    R --> G["accesslog middleware: if !GetSuppressAccessLog l.log\nmiddleware.go:95"]
    R --> U["trackUsage unconditional — bandwidth telemetry preserved"]

Ingestion lands as a ProxyMapping batch on handleSyncMappingsStream/handleMappingStream. processMappings dispatches to addMapping/modifyMapping/removeMapping; HTTP goes setupHTTPMapping → updateMapping → protoToMapping. protoToMapping (server.go:2181) is the single translation surface that materialises []middleware.Spec, *bodytap.Config, AgentNetwork, DisableAccessLog onto each PathTarget; updateMapping finishes with s.proxy.AddMapping(m) (atomic swap under mappingsMux) and s.rebuildMiddlewareChains(svcID, m).

At request time the access-log middleware stamps CapturedData; the auth chain runs (Private services lift peer_group_ids from ValidateTunnelPeer — auth/middleware_test.go:322). ReverseProxy.ServeHTTP resolves the chain; nil or empty → original httputil.ReverseProxy, no body capture. When a chain matches, body is captured under the global budget, RunRequest produces an UpstreamRewrite (llm_router selects a provider, rewrites scheme/host/path, injects Authorization), and RunResponse+RunTerminal run after the upstream returns. The terminal slot sees the merged metadata bag — that's how llm_limit_record ships the consumption sample. The access-log addition: logEntry.AgentNetwork from GetAgentNetwork() onto proto.AccessLog.AgentNetwork; the gate at middleware.go:95 honors EnableLogCollection, skipping l.log but keeping trackUsage so bandwidth telemetry survives.

Public contracts touched

  • proxy.Server.MiddlewareDataDir (string) — base dir for file-backed middleware config (server.go:238-241).
  • proxy.Server.MiddlewareCaptureBudgetBytes (int64) — process-wide capture cap; defaults to 256 MiB (server.go:248-250).
  • proxy/internal/proxy.WithMiddlewareManager(*middleware.Manager) Option — new option on NewReverseProxy; nil keeps the fast path (reverseproxy.go:48-56).
  • proxy/internal/proxy.PathTarget adds Middlewares, CaptureConfig, AgentNetwork, DisableAccessLog (servicemapping.go:27-51), all zero-default.
  • proxy/internal/proxy.CapturedData adds agentNetwork, suppressAccessLog, userGroupNames behind sync.RWMutex; slices deep-copied (context.go:47-66, 183-258).
  • accesslog.logEntry.AgentNetwork + proto.AccessLog.AgentNetwork (logger.go:131, 268).
  • metrics.Metrics.Meter() exposes the OTel meter for the middleware manager (metrics.go:53-58).

Invariants

  • Synth-service updates are live (no proxy restart). Every MODIFIED flows through modifyMapping → cleanupMappingRoutes (invalidates chains) → setupHTTPMapping → updateMapping → rebuildMiddlewareChains. ProxyMapping.Private preservation: the relevant logic lives in management/internals/shared/grpc/proxy.go:shallowCloneMapping, not this module, but it surfaces here — if a MODIFIED synth service arrives private=false, auth skips ValidateTunnelPeer, CapturedData.UserGroups stays empty, and llm_router denies with llm_policy.no_authorised_provider until a management restart re-pushes the snapshot. This module assumes mapping.GetPrivate() is correct on every batch.
  • EnableLogCollection=false suppresses access-log writes but middleware still runs. Gate is one if !cd.GetSuppressAccessLog() immediately around l.log(entry) (middleware.go:95); trackUsage runs below the gate. Locked by TestMiddleware_SuppressAccessLog_PreservesUsageTracking (middleware_test.go:139).
  • agent_network flag on access-log entries is set when the chain processed the request. Source target.AgentNetwork, stamped at reverseproxy.go:105, read at accesslog/middleware.go:86.
  • auth → builtin group propagation. Protect writes UserGroups/UserGroupNames; buildRequestInput (reverseproxy.go:333) copies them into middleware.Input. The response-leg respInput (reverseproxy.go:196-223) also carries UserEmail/UserGroups/UserGroupNamesllm_limit_record needs UserGroups to ship group_ids so management's group-targeted budget rules match (comment at reverseproxy.go:211-215).
  • Empty chains stay on the fast path. ServeHTTP skips body capture and the run sequence when chain == nil || chain.Empty() (reverseproxy.go:127).
  • Self-registration is the only way a builtin reaches the registry. middleware_register.go blank-imports each builtin; init() adds the factory to mwbuiltin.DefaultRegistry(). Missing it → translator drops the entry with a warn (translate.go:97).

Things to scrutinize

Correctness

  • Translate edge cases — drops on nil cfg, empty ID, unknown ID, UNSPECIFIED slot; each logs one warn; volume bounded by MaxMiddlewaresPerChain.
  • Re-translate without dropping in-flight requestsManager.Rebuild is the only call from rebuildMiddlewareChains. Reverse proxy reads ChainFor once per request (reverseproxy.go:327) and runs the captured *Chain for the whole request. Verify in module 30 that Rebuild swaps atomically.
  • ProxyMapping.Private preservation — enforced management-side in shallowCloneMapping. Proxy-side regression catches: TestProtect_PrivateService_TunnelPeerGroupsPropagate + the integration test.
  • Body-capture cleanupdefer releaseBudget() (reverseproxy.go:145) and defer capturingWriter.Release() (reverseproxy.go:180) must run on every return; confirm no future return lands between acquisition and defer.
  • applyUpstreamRewrite clones the URLcloned := *orig value-copies *url.URL; safe because overwritten fields are strings, not slices/maps (reverseproxy.go:285-292).

Security

  • Translate validates every config — registry membership rejects unknown IDs; UNSPECIFIED slot drops; ID-less drops; raw config copied (not aliased) at translate.go:109.
  • AuthHeader/StripHeaders only reachable via UpstreamRewrite — regular mutation surface goes through the framework denylist (Authorization/Cookie blocked); only the router middleware can replace Authorization (reverseproxy.go:296-304). Confirm in module 30 nothing outside the proxy-trusted path populates UpstreamRewrite.AuthHeader.
  • stampNetBirdIdentity strips client-sent values first (reverseproxy.go:742-743) — anti-spoof for X-NetBird-User/X-NetBird-Groups; control chars filtered; comma-bearing labels dropped (reverseproxy_test.go:1217/:1243/:1193).
  • Auth → group propagationauth/middleware_test.go:322 and :366 cover the contract. If auth ever stops calling ValidateTunnelPeer for Private services, every agent-network request silently denies.

Concurrency

  • Chain replacement under in-flight requestsfindTargetForRequest takes mappingsMux.RLock; AddMapping writes. resolveChain calls ChainFor once; even if Rebuild swaps mid-request, in-flight requests keep running on the captured pointer.
  • CapturedData mutation across slots — accessors take sync.RWMutex; slices deep-copied on both Set and Get. Verify no caller mutates the returned slice expecting it to land back.
  • Manager.Invalidate raceremoveMapping invalidates after cleanupMappingRoutes; mapping read happens before chain resolution, so requests before invalidate run captured chains; later ones fail findTargetForRequest.
  • Logger.log goroutinelogSem caps at maxLogWorkers = 4096; overflow → dropped.Add(1) + debug log. Middleware test uses a buffered channel and 150ms negative-assertion window — review whether 150ms holds on slow CI.

Backward compatibility

  • Non-agent-network services unaffectedprotoToMapping reads new fields only when opts != nil; defaults leave Middlewares/CaptureConfig nil → chain resolves nil → fast path. Existing reverseproxy_test.go (non-chain) still passes.
  • disable_access_log is proto field 13, default false — every existing target unset; gate is no-op. Locked by TestMiddleware_SuppressAccessLog_DefaultEmitsLog (middleware_test.go:104).
  • Server additions optional — 256 MiB default when MiddlewareCaptureBudgetBytes ≤ 0 (server.go:1997-2000).

Performance

  • Translate cost per push — O(n) with per-entry registry lookup and config_json copy; negligible vs. the upstream gRPC unmarshal.
  • Empty-chain hot path — one ChainFor map lookup + one chain.Empty() check; no allocation delta vs. pre-PR.
  • Body capture buffer churnbodytap.CaptureRequest allocates MaxRequestBytes per chain-hitting request; releaseBudget ties allocation to the 256 MiB proxy-wide budget. Confirm in module 30 the budget is a hard cap.

Observability

  • MetricsMetrics.Meter() shared with middleware.NewMetrics (server.go:1990-1993) so middleware instruments land in the same prometheus exporter. No new metrics defined here.
  • Access-log accuracy — every entry carries AgentNetwork; terminal-slot metadata merged into CapturedData.Metadata (reverseproxy.go:238-241).
  • Deny logs at Infof (reverseproxy.go:170) — review whether Info is too noisy at high deny rates; consider Debug or rate-limit.

Test coverage

Test file Locks down
proxy/middleware_translate_test.go Empty/nil → nil; field preservation; unknown ID skip; nil registry permissive; timeout clamping; fail-mode + slot incl. UNSPECIFIED-drop; empty-ID drop; truncation above + at MaxMiddlewaresPerChain
proxy/internal/proxy/reverseproxy_test.go Rewrite host/headers/cookies/query; trusted proxy; path forwarding; classifyProxyError; X-NetBird-User/Groups anti-spoof + CSV-join + control-char/comma rejection + fallback-to-ID; TestBuildRequestInput_PropagatesIdentityAndGroups (UserGroups/Email/GroupNames/AgentNetwork reach middleware.Input)
proxy/internal/proxy/agent_network_chain_realstack_test.go The end-to-end integration test. Drives a real agent-network request through ReverseProxy.ServeHTTP with the chain the synthesizer produces, against an in-process management gRPC (bufconn) backed by a real sqlite store + real agentnetwork.Manager, plus an httptest upstream — no external infrastructure or real LLM. Guarantees: (1) response-leg respInput carries UserGroups so llm_limit_record ships non-empty group_ids and the admin-group consumption row increments; (2) RedactPii=true redacts both prompt and completion on captured metadata; (3) the full chain runs against a real management stack. Line 189-211 inlines the proto→Spec mapping instead of calling the proxy's private translateMiddlewareConfig — keep that inline mirror in sync with proxy/middleware_translate.go or the test silently diverges from production.
proxy/internal/accesslog/middleware_test.go SuppressAccessLog=true skips SendAccessLog (150ms negative wait); default emits one send (2s positive); usage tracking runs under suppression
proxy/internal/auth/middleware_test.go TestProtect_PrivateService_TunnelPeerGroupsPropagate proves peer_group_ids reach CapturedData.UserGroups; TestProtect_PrivateService_TunnelPeerDenied proves rejected peers 403 without reaching the handler

The integration test runs in a few seconds with no external infrastructure — exercising the real synthesizer, Manager.Rebuild, ServeHTTP dispatch, and llm_limit_record writing a real consumption row through the real agentnetwork.Manager over real gRPC.

Known limitations / explicit non-goals

  • Translator does not validate RawConfig JSON — factory's job at New([]byte). Confirm in module 30 that a per-binding factory failure doesn't poison the rest of the chain.
  • No throttle on management push rate — every MODIFIED triggers Manager.Rebuild. Mitigation upstream.
  • Streaming responses (SSE) — body capture is streaming-aware, but response-leg middleware runs only after the response completes; long SSE streams delay llm_limit_record until close.
  • OIDC-only path doesn't carry tunnel-peer groups — agent-network synth services rely on the Private tunnel-peer path; JWT groups claim is the only carrier for non-Private OIDC.
  • agent_network flag on L4 entries not added; HTTP-only.
  • mw.capture.bypass_reason metadata key documented at reverseproxy.go:151,184; namespace this in module 30/31 to avoid collisions.

Cross-references