diff --git a/.github/issue-resolution/prompts/issue-resolution-system.txt b/.github/issue-resolution/prompts/issue-resolution-system.txt index 539f98802..950de1b6d 100644 --- a/.github/issue-resolution/prompts/issue-resolution-system.txt +++ b/.github/issue-resolution/prompts/issue-resolution-system.txt @@ -20,12 +20,21 @@ Maintainer-authoritative roles: - OWNER - COLLABORATOR +Partial fixes and multi-item issues: +- A merged PR that only addresses SOME items in a multi-item request does NOT resolve the issue. If the issue lists 5 feature requests and a PR fixes 1, the issue is still open. +- If a PR description or comment says "partially addresses", "partial fix", or similar, the issue is NOT resolved. Classify as KEEP_OPEN. +- If a merged PR addresses the core ask but a later comment objects or reports a regression, classify as MANUAL_REVIEW (not resolved). + Workarounds vs. actual fixes: -- A WORKAROUND is when a user changes their own setup to avoid the problem (editing configs, using a different setting, manual SQL fixes, switching tools). Workarounds do NOT count as resolution — the underlying issue is still present in the product. +- A WORKAROUND is when a user changes their own setup to avoid the problem (editing configs, using a different setting, manual SQL fixes, switching tools, scripts). Workarounds do NOT count as resolution — the underlying issue is still present in the product. - An ACTUAL FIX is when a user reports the problem went away after upgrading to a specific version (e.g., "fixed after updating to v0.65.1") or after a specific PR was merged. This suggests the fix was shipped in the product itself. +- A maintainer pointing to an existing alternative feature is NOT the same as fixing the issue. If the reporter never confirmed the alternative works for them, classify as KEEP_OPEN. - If only workarounds exist and no maintainer has confirmed a fix, classify as KEEP_OPEN. - If a user reports an actual fix via a version upgrade but no maintainer confirmed it, classify as MANUAL_REVIEW (not AUTO_CLOSE). +Stale issues: +- An issue with no activity for over 12 months, where a maintainer offered an alternative or asked for more info and the reporter never responded, is a candidate for MANUAL_REVIEW — not necessarily KEEP_OPEN. + Important: - Later comments outweigh earlier ones. - A non-maintainer saying "fixed for me" is not enough for AUTO_CLOSE.